AG1 (Athletic Greens) vs. Green Vibrance: Which Is Better?

AG1 Next Gen and Green Vibrance are both sought-after greens powder formulas, although each is compositionally different and provides consumers with different health benefits. In this review, I’ll explain why these two supplements are revered in the market and break down their pros and cons. I will also be exploring how to decide which supplement is best suited for your specific needs and if there are better greens powder alternatives.

Comparison Chart

→ Why I recommend Live it Up Super Greens instead: The Super Greens powder is an excellent supplement for nutrition, digestion, energy and immune support. The delicious and affordable formula is packed with 20+ natural superfoods, including probiotics, digestive enzymes, and dietary fiber.

AG1 (Athletic Greens) Overview

Athletic Greens Next Gen (AG1) is an extremely popular super greens formula within the health and wellbeing market. The formula’s popularity is growing exponentially year over year due to the positive feedback from not only real customers but from athletes, celebrities, and fitness influencers, too.

Packed with over 80 impressive all-natural ingredients, including a wide range of whole-food super greens as well as probiotics, prebiotics, adaptogens, and enzymes, it’s not difficult to see why this formula attracts so many people at an initial glance.

AG1 Pros

• Contains 83 non-GMO ingredients
• Vegan-friendly, gluten-free, sugar-free, and nut-free
• Popular with athletes, celebrities, and fitness influencers
• Comes in four flavors (original, berry, citrus, and tropical)
• No added sugar or artificial flavors 
• Probiotics and a digestive enzyme

AG1 Cons

• More expensive than other formulas on average, per serving
• Contains synthetically derived nutrients
• Many vitamins exceed the daily recommended values.
• Sweetened with stevia leaf extract, which creates an artificial taste
• Contains soy and filler (silica)
• Texture can be a bit grainy

Green Vibrance by Vibrant Health Overview

Green Vibrance by Vibrant Health has been on the market since 1992 and has won the highest number of prestigious awards for its brilliance as a healthy formula. This brand not only has a long legacy, but it’s also the most awarded greens supplement on the market, which shows just how reliable the formula is. 

Vibrant Health Green Vibrance also contains over 70 ingredients, including potent super greens ingredients, fruits, enzymes, probiotics, prebiotics, herbs, extracts, and more.

Green Vibrance Pros

• Over 70 fully-disclosed ingredients 
• Highly sought after and acclaimed
• Low cost
• Comes in three flavor options (original, chocolate coconut, blueberry lemon)
• Vegan and non-GMO 
• Probiotics and digestive enzymes

Green Vibrance Cons

• Doesn’t dissolve well, leaving a gritty, grainy texture
• The grassy, unpleasant taste is hard to get past
• Many vitamins and minerals exceed the daily recommended values 

AG1 vs. Green Vibrance Benefits

There are many benefits to integrating a green powder supplement into your daily diet. However, there are a few differences between AG1 Next Gen and Vibrant Health Green Vibrance.

AG1 Benefits

AG1 has gone to the effort of dedicating an entire part of their website to the advantages of the formula. Next Gen offers the following purported benefits: 

1. Digestive support: The blend includes 10 billion CFU of five different strains of probiotics, probiotics (inulin), and digestive enzymes to aid digestion and gut health. 
2. Immune function: It features algae, cereal grasses, and greens, which contain immune-supporting nutrients, including vitamins A, C, and E, as well as zinc and selenium. 
3. Nutritional support: The formula is packed with vitamins and minerals, including B vitamins, calcium, zinc, iron, and selenium. However, they are synthetic nutrients (not derived from whole foods), and many of the quantities exceed the daily recommended values. 
4. Reduced stress levels: It includes adaptogens, such as astragalus and ashwagandha, which may help manage stress and anxiety. However, it’s unclear whether the doses align with daily recommendations and are possibly underdosed. 
5. Cell protection: The powder contains antioxidant-rich ingredients, such as mushrooms and berries, which can help protect cells and combat oxidative stress. 

Green Vibrance Benefits

Green Vibrance is designed to help the user with whole-body wellness due to the health benefits they state are in the formula. These health benefits are built around the four pillars of health wellness—nutrition, circulation, digestion, and immunity:

1. Nutritional support: The blend comprises a variety of nutrient-rich ingredients, including cereal grasses, algae, greens, and fruits. However, many of the nutrient quantities exceed the daily recommended values. 
2. Energy maintenance and digestion: It features six digestive enzymes, which help break down food and convert it into energy.  Plus, the formula includes 12 strains of probiotics to support a healthy microbiome.
3. Immune function: The overall formula contains a variety of nutrients that support immunity (vitamins A, C, D, zinc, and selenium), but it also includes an immune-support specific blend with astragalus and ResistAid®.
4. Circulation: It includes nutrient-dense ingredients that may support circulation, such as beetroot powder, kale, and spinach. 

AG1 vs. Green Vibrance Ingredients

Ingredients can make or break the quality of a green powder supplement. Here are the key ingredients and how they can affect your daily intake of nutrients.

AG1 Ingredients

The Athletic Greens formula contains 83 healthy ingredients, including prebiotics, probiotics, enzymes, and adaptogens. The super greens powder is vegan, gluten-free, nut-free, dairy-free, keto-friendly, paleo-friendly, and non-GMO, making it suitable for a wide range of people with food-specific allergies.

Let’s take a closer look at some of the AG1 ingredients:

• Active Superfood and Prebiotic Complex: This fiber-rich blend includes prebiotics, such as inulin and apple powder, along with digestive enzymes like bromelain, as well as herbs, algae, and adaptogens like astragalus, ashwagandha, and rhodiola. 
• Daily Phytonutrient Blend: This blend is an excellent source of antioxidants and immune-supporting ingredients, including cereal grass, greens, berries, and mushrooms. 
• Dairy-free Probiotic Blend: Including 10 billion CFUs of five different strains of probiotics, which is at the top end of the recommended dose range.

While AG1 Next Gen contains a variety of superfoods, I do wonder if the formula is over-stuffed. Sometimes, when a blend has too many ingredients, they can be underdosed, thereby limiting their potential health benefits.

Green Vibrance Ingredients

Green Vibrance contains over 70 ingredients, just like the Athletic Greens formula. Containing everything from super greens and probiotics to herbs and enzymes, the formula is vegan, gluten-free, dairy-free, and non-GMO.

Below, I’ve outlined some of the key ingredients in the Green Vibrance formula: 

• Cereal Grasses and Plant-Based Micro-Nutrition: The blend includes a variety of nutrient-dense cereal grasses, algae, leafy greens, and cruciferous vegetables.  
• Antioxidant Life Preservers: The formula includes fruits such as strawberries, pomegranates, and goji berries that may help combat oxidative stress. 
• Fiber, Probiotics, Enzymes, Tonics: With inulin (prebiotics), six digestive enzymes, and 12 different strains of probiotics, these ingredients focus on gut support. 

When it comes to Green Vibrance’s ingredient list, I have the same concern I had with AG1 Next Gen. It’s great to see so many superfoods and healthy ingredients included in the formula, but I wonder if their doses are enough to offer significant health benefits.

AG1 vs. Green Vibrance Taste

It’s not enough that it’s healthy. In order for us to take anything every day, it has to taste great! So, what do these greens taste like?

Athletic Greens Taste

In addition to the Original flavor, AG1 Next Gen now also comes in Tropical, Citrus, and Berry flavors.

Athletic Greens is naturally sweetened using stevia extract, and it’s also flavored using papaya, broccoli powder, cherry powder, carrot, natural pineapple flavor, and natural vanilla flavor. There are a lot of flavorings used to alter the taste of this formula, with mixed results. 

While some love the subtle taste of the flavorings and the refreshing nature of the formula, others despise how it tastes. The presence of stevia can also create an unpleasant aftertaste. However, the flavor is rarely overpowering, but the formula doesn’t mix well, resulting in a grainy texture when the formula settles.

Green Vibrance Taste

Green Vibrance is available in three flavors: original, chocolate coconut, and matcha tea.

The original flavor contains a flavoring ingredient known as Vanifolia. The chocolate coconut flavor uses natural caramel chocolate coconut flavoring, monk fruit, cocoa powder, and the Vanifolia natural flavoring. The matcha tea flavor simply contains monk fruit extract, vanilla natural flavoring, and the basic Vanifolia natural flavoring. 

The formula is commonly described as having a grass-like taste and leaving a gritty texture behind. Personally, I found the taste to be one of the most unpleasant of all the green powders I’ve tasted. It was overly sweet and grassy with a lingering bitter aftertaste. 

AG1 vs. Green Vibrance Cost

Which is more affordable? Here’s a breakdown of the cost between Athletic Greens and Green Vibrance.

AG1 Cost

AG1 is one of the more expensive super greens formulas on the market, making it unaffordable for a lot of people. Let’s take a closer look:

• $79 ($2.64 per serving) for a 30-day supply with a subscription
• $99 for a one-time purchase of a 30-day supply 
• $149 ($2.64 per serving) for a 60-day supply with a subscription
• $198 for a one-time purchase of a 60-day supply
• $223.50 ($2.49 per serving) for a 90-day supply with a subscription
• $297 for a 90-day supply with a subscription
• 90-day money-back guarantee with a subscription

Green Vibrance Cost

Green Vibrance is relatively low-cost compared to AG1 and many other super green formulas. Its pricing is as follows:

• $56 ($1.87 per serving) for a 30-day supply with a subscription
• $65 for a one-time purchase of a 30-day supply
• $84.85 ($1.41 per serving) for a 60-day supply with a subscription
• $99 for a one-time purchase of a 60-day supply
• $111.42 ($1.34 per serving) for an 83-day supply
• $130 for a one-time purchase of an 83-day supply
• Free shipping on orders $55+
• 90-day satisfaction guarantee

AG1 vs. Green Vibrance: Which Is Better?

In terms of the number of ingredients, the average grams per serving, and the methods of attaining the super green, I’d have to say that these two formulas are pretty close to one another. They both contain a variety of superfoods and include nutrients that exceed the daily recommended values. 

That said, AG1 Next Gen is considerably more expensive than Green Vibrance, which may be a deterrent for some. However, it does have a much more enjoyable flavor than Green Vibrance, making it easier to incorporate into your daily routine.

Now, if you are looking for the best AG1 alternatives, there are a few other options available on the market. These greens powders offer similar benefits to Athletic Greens and Green Vibrance, and can be a great option for those looking for a different taste or price point.  For example, Live it Up Super Greens is one of my favorite choices.

My Recommendation: Live it Up Super Greens

I strongly recommend Live it Up Super Greens because I believe it is the best green powder to support your energy levels, gut health, immune system, and overall health. Live it Up Super Greens is incredibly affordable, with high-quality probiotic and enzyme blends. It also tastes great and easily dissolves into water, almond milk, smoothies, and more. 

Live it Up is committed to high-quality products with superfoods you can rely on. Key benefits of Live it Up blends:

• Non-GMO ingredients and organic vegetables
• Commitment to all-natural, non-synthetic ingredients
• Energizing superfoods
• 100% plant-based and vegan-friendly
• Gluten-free
• No dairy
• No soy
• No artificial flavors, sweeteners, fillers, or added sugars
• GMP-certified
• Third-party tested

Live it Up Super Greens is a great first step toward better health, so there’s no risk in giving it a try!

FAQs About Green Vibrance vs. AG1

Follow along to find out the answers to your FAQs.

Which is better, Green Vibrance or AG1?

Green Vibrance and AG1 Next Gen both offer nutrient-dense greens powders with a variety of superfoods. They also contain prebiotics, digestive enzymes, and probiotics. AG1 is significantly more expensive than Green Vibrance, which may be a turn-off for those on a budget. While Green Vibrance is the more affordable option, many customers dislike its unpleasant, grassy taste.

What greens powder is better than AG1?

My go-to greens powder is Live it Up Super Greens. Not only does it taste delicious and have an affordable price tag, but it also contains 20+ non-GMO, all-natural superfoods, essential nutrients, digestive enzymes, probiotics, and dietary fiber with prebiotics. Moreover, it's free of gluten, soy, added sugars, and artificial sweeteners.

Is Live it Up Super Greens better than AG1?

Yes, in my opinion, I believe Live it Up Super Greens is better than AG1 Next Gen for several reasons. For one, Live it Up features all-natural vitamins and minerals derived from whole foods, while AG1 contains synthetic nutrients. Live it Up also has a delicious taste, which is enhanced by monk fruit, while AG1 contains stevia, which can be overly sweet and create a bitter aftertaste. Furthermore, Live it Up is a much more affordable option than AG1.